One of the most common questions I get asked as a dog trainer is "Which breed is the easiest to train?" Whether you're thinking about getting a puppy or wondering why your current dog isn't responding to training as quickly as you'd hoped, it's natural to wonder if some breeds simply pick things up faster than others.
I wish I could give you a definitive list of "Top 5 Most Trainable Dogs" but the reality is far more nuanced and, dare I say, much more interesting. Let's dig into what actually makes a dog "easy" to train, beyond their breed.
What Makes a Dog 'Easy' to Train?
Before we even think about breed characteristics, we need to consider what's happening beneath the surface. A dog needs to be:
Happy and comfortable in their own skin: A confident, emotionally balanced dog who's been well-socialised will always learn faster than one who's anxious or fearful. If your dog is spending all their energy worrying about their surroundings, they simply don't have the mental bandwidth to focus on learning new tricks.
Physically well: This might seem obvious, but it's often overlooked. If your dog is experiencing pain or even mild discomfort you might not notice, they're not going to be enthusiastic about training. We often blame the dog, saying "you don't want to learn" or "you're being stubborn," when actually there might be something else going on.
In the right emotional state: A dog who's either too nervous or too excited won't be able to learn effectively. Humans are the same. If you're extremely anxious or bouncing off the walls with excitement, are you able to concentrate on learning new information? Probably not and dogs are no different.
These factors matter far more than breed when it comes to trainability. They're often things we can influence through thoughtful socialisation and creating the right learning environment.
The Reward Factor
Different dogs are motivated by different rewards and this can really affect how "easy" they are to train. We tend to think of rewards as just treats, but dogs can be motivated by:
- Food (the obvious one)
- Toys and play
- Attention and praise
- Environmental rewards, like getting to sniff or explore
- Breed-specific rewards - activities they were bred to enjoy
This last category is particularly interesting. Every breed was developed for a specific purpose and what they were bred to do is often intrinsically rewarding to them.
My labradors, for example, were bred as retrievers. It’s literally in their name. Carrying things in their mouth makes them feel good. It's why my dogs greet me with something in their mouths when they're excited. I don't need to reward this behaviour - just holding something is rewarding enough.
Spaniels love to sniff and flush out prey. Collies are deeply rewarded by herding movements. Dachshunds were bred for hunting badgers.
Some breeds have rewards that are easier to simulate in everyday life than others. This is actually why I stick with gun dog breeds – I find I can easily recreate the activities they find naturally rewarding. If you have a collie but no sheep or a bully breed with no bull to bait, you might need to get more creative with substitutions!
This doesn't make these breeds "harder" to train. It just means you need to think outside the box a bit more to tap into what genuinely motivates them.
The Human Factor
Here's where it gets even more complicated. The "easiest" breed for you might be the hardest breed for me, depending on:
- Our experience levels
- Our own energy and temperament
- How much time we have
- Our creativity and problem-solving abilities
- Our mechanical skills (timing, coordination, etc.)
Dog training is genuinely an art form. It requires knowledge, timing, coordination, the ability to read situations, adapt on the fly and remember countless exercises. It's no wonder many dog owners say their second dog was easier to train – they'd already practiced all these skills.
I often think of Dave, my first puppy, as my "practice run." I made mistakes with him like letting him say hello to everyone, which is why he now wants to greet every person he sees. Was that his breed traits, his genetics or my influence? It's impossible to say.
By my fourth dog, I'd learned so much more but each dog has been completely different, requiring me to adapt my approach:
- Dave is easy with food rewards but limited by health conditions affecting his stamina
- Rem’s a quick learner but challenging because he gets overexcited, meaning I have to match his energy and be one step ahead
- Fred lacks the drive of the others, will do something once and then decide "no thanks"
Were any of them "easier" than the others? No, just different.
The Myth of the "Stubborn" Breed
You've probably heard people say certain breeds are "stubborn" or "notoriously difficult to train." This always makes me smile because dogs lack the emotional development to be stubborn.
What people are actually describing is a dog that's unmotivated. We haven't figured out what rewards work for them or we're expecting too much too soon.
Some breeds do require a more experienced handler who can tap into their specific needs and motivations. It's not as simple as just throwing them a treat. They might need those environmental or breed-specific rewards we talked about earlier.
Finding Your Perfect Match
So what's the easiest breed to train? For me, it's a labrador but only because I understand them, I know what motivates them and our energies match well. That doesn't mean labs are the easiest for everyone.
Interestingly, while labradors are often recommended as first-time dogs, I actually think they can be challenging for beginners. They're big, strong, enthusiastic and want to say hello to everyone which isn’t always easy to manage when you're learning the ropes yourself.
The secret is finding a breed that matches YOU – your lifestyle, your experience level and what you're willing to put into training. It’s a bit like speed dating. A good match is one where your energies, expectations and capabilities align.
Remember that the relationship with your dog is a 50/50 partnership. It's about how well you work together as a team.
So rather than asking "Which breed is easiest to train?", perhaps the better question is: "Which breed is the best match for me, given my experience, lifestyle and what I can offer?"
If you fancy a chat about this or any other doggy-related topic, head over to the
Potter Paws Facebook Group. We’re a supportive community of dog owners sharing experiences and advice and we love welcoming new members. Come join us!
Hear more about this topic: